After months of renovating a stale comfort retailer and honest-tuning recipes, the householders of Kitty’s House of Pizza are on the point of welcome their first possibilities next month in St. Pete’s Central Oak Park neighborhood.
The pizzeria at 4059 5th Avenue North will encourage scratch-made pies that householders Steve Garrahan and Kurt Drake hope will give within sight residents one thing to crave.
Garrahan and Drake, the founders of Gleaming Ice Scoop Shop, first announced the theory in December 2025. Since then, they’ve been developing a limited menu built round familiar flavors with about a surprising components.
“We desire the pizzas to be obvious, nonetheless we don’t desire them to be abnormal for the sake of being abnormal,” Garrahan mentioned in a conversation with St. Pete Rising.
One amongst the householders’ favorites is the Golden Hour, which comprises a creamy pepperoncini pepper white mistaken with mozzarella, housemade sausage, purple onions, pepperoncini rings, and roasted purple peppers.
The Aloha Kitty is a twist on Hawaiian pizza, featuring a candy-and-luscious pineapple jam with candy onion, purple bell pepper, jalapeño, and lime juice.
It’s an potential Gleaming Ice possibilities can also honest glance. On the pair’s scoop shops, strawberry ice cream turns into roasted strawberries with brown sugar and balsamic, whereas blueberry gets a contact of cinnamon.
At Kitty’s, that creativity shall be concentrated into nine uniqueness pizzas and a assemble-your-relish option, available as 12-poke and 16-poke total pies.
Diversified alternatives encompass a 3-mushroom pizza and a pie featuring a salsa verde-impressed sauce with parsley, basil, and lemon.
The dough, made with unbleached, unbromated flour, will ferment for Forty eight to 72 hours sooner than baking in a brick oven at roughly 550 degrees.
Costs are aloof being finalized, nonetheless the householders desire dinner at Kitty’s to be an cheap different to procuring and cooking for a family.
“We’re repeatedly attempting to ponder the value we are in a position to give to our customer,” Drake mentioned. “Why would they pick us?”
Beyond pizza, the crew is developing a limited sequence of pastas, salads, starters, and desserts.
Dishes being tested encompass meatballs with purple pepper sauce and lemon-Parmesan ricotta, on the side of gigante butter beans in a Parmesan cream sauce with solar-dried tomatoes and roasted purple peppers.
For dessert, Kitty’s will supply a coconut cake with salted caramel buttercream amongst other selections. Gleaming Ice pints will additionally be available to rob home.
Garrahan and Drake purchased the 2,834-sq.-foot property in June 2025 whereas purchasing for a better Gleaming Ice manufacturing facility. The extra space gave them room to originate a restaurant alongside it, naming Kitty’s after Garrahan’s daughter’s cat.
The stale comfort retailer became stripped relief to its exterior walls and rebuilt as a 26-seat dining room with terrazzo flooring, wood finishes, and a palette of green, orange and blue.
Long-established plans for the building, in-built 1964 as a Shell gas put, helped recordsdata its restoration.
Kitty’s will essentially point of interest on carryout for lunch and dinner, with plans to be succesful of add approximately 22 open air seats later.
The adjoining manufacturing facility will replace Gleaming Ice’s Pinellas Park put and double its ice cream storage skill.
The householders are focused on a November subtle opening, pending final inspections.
Grunt Kitty’s House of Pizza on Instagram for opening and menu updates.
Leave a Reply